Tories and Lib Dems defend local press mimicry after editor’s ‘dirty tricks’ jibe

Report by David Sharman for HTFP

The Conservative Party and Liberal Democrats have defended their mimicry of local newspapers following a publisher’s fresh criticism of the practice.

Duncan Williams has hit out at what he called “dirty tricks” after discovering the Tories are running a pamphlet called the Tiverton and Honiton Telegraph, while the Liberal Democrats are also posting a title called the Devon News Courier through doors.

Duncan’s criticism has prompted the Tories to defend the tactic nationally, claiming readers will not “be under any illusions that it’s from a political party.”

Duncan owns historic South-East Devon title Pulman’s Weekly News, which he is currently running as an online news aggregation service.

He said: “The recent dirty tricks used by some political parties, who print and publish one-off, pseudo local newspapers, filled with biased coverage in favour of their own candidates, is unacceptable and deceptive.

“Be wary of these fake papers, if they are ever pushed through your letterbox, I suggest you bin them.

“They are particularly galling to those of us working in the genuine news industry, who know too well the struggles involved in keeping a real newspaper brand alive and kicking.”

In response, a spokesman for the Conservatives said: “Any literature from the party has to clearly state that it is from the party.

“I don’t think people who read them will be under any illusions that it’s from a political party.”

A Lib Dem spokesperson added: “All our campaigning literature in Devon makes clear they are from the Liberal Democrats on the front page.

“Having a strong local media plays a critical role in holding those in power to account and we will continue to work closely with local newspapers.”

HTFP reported last month how Hereford Times editor John Wilson had succeeded in getting local Tories on his patch to pledge to discontinue the practice after criticised the North Herefordshire Conservative Association for publishing a pamphlet under the name ‘Herefordshire Champion’.

John’s criticism prompted a U-turn by the Association, which had initially defended the practice on the grounds that CCHQ had offered local branches predetermined templates for pamphlets ahead of May’s elections.

https://www.holdthefrontpage.co.uk/2023/news/editor-hits-out-at-tory-and-lib-dem-dirty-tricks-amid-fresh-local-press-mimicry/

ELECTION TIME IS WHEN WE OUGHT TO VALUE LOCAL JOURNALISM ALL THE MORE - 📰🗞️

 Report from the Editor's Desk by Duncan Williams

The local elections are fast approaching and as someone who values the importance of a free and democratic society, I believe that regional journalism has a vital role to play in upholding local democracy now more than ever. In today's world, where social media and big tech companies dominate the news landscape, it is becoming increasingly difficult for local communities to stay informed about the issues that affect our daily lives. This is where regional journalism comes in, and I am proud to be a part of it.

On 4th May, 2023, British people across the country are invited to go to the polls to select our district councillors, unitary authorities, and directly-elected mayors. A lot of choices need to be made and sometimes we may require a little extra help sifting through the chaff and wheat.

Did you know, sometimes political candidates don't tell the truth?

Regional journalism serves as a watchdog for local communities, shining a light on the actions of local governments, businesses, and individuals. It is through the work of regional journalists that we are able to hold those in power accountable and ensure that they are acting in the best interests of their constituents. Without this type of journalism, it is all too easy for those in power to operate in the shadows, making decisions that benefit themselves rather than the communities they serve.

In addition to holding those in power accountable, regional journalism also plays a vital role in keeping communities informed about important issues. This is especially important in today's world, where misinformation and fake news are rampant.

The recent dirty tricks used by some political parties, who print and publish one-off, pseudo local newspapers, filled with bias coverage in favour of their own candidates, is unacceptable and deceptive. Be wary of these fake papers, if they are ever pushed through your letterbox, I suggest you bin them. They are particularly galling to those of us working in the genuine news industry, who know too well the struggles involved in keeping a real newspaper brand alive and kicking.

By providing accurate and trustworthy information, real journalists help to combat the spread of misinformation and ensure that local communities are making informed decisions.

Furthermore, regional journalism also helps to foster a sense of community and belonging. By reporting on local events, issues, and individuals, regional journalists help to create a shared sense of identity among local residents. This is especially important in today's world, where many people feel isolated and disconnected from their communities.

Despite the vital role that local journalism plays in upholding democracy, it is facing unprecedented challenges. The decline of print media, the rise of digital media, and the dominance of big tech companies have all contributed to a decline in regional journalism. Many local newspapers have closed down, and those that remain are often struggling to stay afloat.

Pulman's is a heritage brand that has provided trusted news since 1857. As editor, I am fortunate to have a small but dedicated team that feels passionate about our work.

It is imperative that we recognise the importance of journalism and take steps to support it. This includes investing in local newspapers, whether electronic or print, supporting local journalists, and encouraging the development of new and innovative media outlets. By doing so, we can ensure that local communities have access to the information they need to make informed decisions, hold those in power accountable, and maintain a healthy and vibrant democracy.